“America - a great social and economic experiment,
noble in motive and far-reaching in purpose.”
Herbert Hoover
I don’t often find myself agreeing with Herbert Hoover. His response to the Great Depression was so ineffective that historians regularly rank him among America’s worst presidents. But on this point, I think he got it right.
America is an experiment. Or at least it was supposed to be.
Not a promise of perfection. Not a guarantee of prosperity. An experiment. A bold, messy attempt to prove that people with wildly different backgrounds, beliefs, and ambitions could build a nation rooted in life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
Experiments don’t always succeed. Sometimes they reveal uncomfortable truths.
As America celebrates its 250th birthday tomorrow, I can’t help wondering whether we’re honoring the experiment...or pretending it hasn’t gone spectacularly off the rails.
Instead of using this milestone to reflect on where we’ve been, where we are, and where we hope to go, we got Conald Chump’s version of America: all spectacle and no substance.
Freedom 250, not to be confused with the official America 250 celebration, feels less like a tribute to the nation than a birthday party for a wannabe dick-tator. Instead of reflecting on our history, we’ve been handed a carefully choreographed production featuring oversized flags, military pageantry, campaign slogans masquerading as patriotism, and enough self-congratulatory bullshit to make even a narcissist blush.
Fireworks can be impressive. But the message behind them is usually less inspiring.
The Founding Fathers were brave and brilliant. But they were also deeply flawed.
Many spoke passionately about liberty while enslaving other human beings. Women had virtually no political rights. Indigenous people were displaced and erased in the name of conquest and expansion. Equality was reserved only for a privileged few.
Let’s not pretend otherwise. But let’s also acknowledge what they accomplished.
Despite their many contradictions, the Founders created something extraordinary. They didn’t claim to have built a perfect nation. They built a framework for one. A Constitution that could be amended. A government with checks and balances. A system designed to limit power instead of concentrating it. A peaceful transfer of power that became the envy of the world.
They understood something we’ve forgotten: Democracy isn’t a destination. It’s an ongoing negotiation. The Declaration of Independence didn’t describe America as it existed. It described America as it could become.
“All men are created equal” wasn’t a statement of fact in 1776. It was an aspiration.
Every generation since has been challenged to make those words a little more true. To widen the circle. To make “We the People” include more people than it did before.
That’s the experiment. Not whether America can become richer. But whether America can become fairer.
Somewhere along the way, we stopped measuring success by how many people had a seat at the table and started measuring it by how much money the ruling class had amassed.
Even worse, we started confusing capitalism with democracy.
They are not the same thing!
Democracy gives every citizen a vote.
Capitalism gives every dollar a vote.
And when wealth becomes concentrated in fewer and fewer hands, those dollars begin speaking much louder than the rest of us.
Today, nearly a thousand American billionaires control more wealth than most of us can even comprehend. Elon Musk’s fortune alone is so enormous that it has become almost abstract. When one person can spend hundreds of millions influencing elections without noticeably affecting their bank account, we’re no longer talking about free markets. We’re talking about oligarchy.
Before somebody rushes into the comments screaming, “Move to Cuba!” let me save you the trouble.
I’m not arguing against markets. I’m arguing against worshipping them.
One possible alternative is democratic socialism. Contrary to what its critics often claim, it isn’t about government owning everything. It’s about recognizing that some things are so fundamental to a healthy society that they shouldn’t be treated as luxury items reserved for whoever can afford them:
A living wage
Affordable housing
Healthcare
Public education
Clean air
Safe drinking water
The ability to retire before your obituary appears
These aren’t extravagant demands. They're the bare minimum for any society that claims to value human dignity.
Capitalism has accomplished incredible things. It has fueled innovation, rewarded entrepreneurship, and lifted millions of people out of poverty.
It has also rewarded greed, encouraged monopolies, weakened labor unions, hollowed out the middle class, and convinced countless Americans that their value as human beings is measured by the size of their paycheck.
Capitalism is a remarkable servant. It’s a terrible master.
Meanwhile, we’ve turned billionaires into celebrities and celebrities into billionaires.
While I’m not a fan of her music, I have nothing against Taylor Swift. But watching the internet collectively obsess over every detail of a billionaire’s wedding while millions of Americans worry about making rent feels...off.
Not because joy is frivolous. But because distraction has become an industry.
We’re arguing over celebrity guest lists while corporate lobbyists rewrite legislation. We’re debating designer gowns while billionaires quietly buy newspapers, social media platforms, politicians, and public opinion.
It’s easier to sell fairy tales than fairness. Maybe it always has been.
Freedom isn’t free. Maybe it never was.
Democracy requires participation. Curiosity. Compromise. Accountability. It demands that ordinary people stay engaged, even when they’re exhausted. It asks us to defend institutions we didn’t create and rights we may never personally need.
Capitalism asks a much simpler question: What’s profitable?
Those aren’t the same values.
One creates citizens. The other creates consumers.
One measures the common good. The other measures quarterly earnings.
So here we are.
Two hundred and fifty years into what Herbert Hoover called “a great social and economic experiment.”
We’ve allowed extraordinary wealth to become extraordinary political power.
We’ve confused nationalism with patriotism.
We’ve mistaken consumer choice for civic engagement.
We’ve let billionaires convince us that what’s good for their portfolios is automatically good for America. It isn’t.
The American experiment was never supposed to produce kings.
Not hereditary kings
Not corporate kings
Not political kings
Not trillionaire kings
Democracy is still worth fighting for because it belongs to all of us.
Capitalism deserves a seat at the table. But it should never own the table.
So yes, enjoy the fireworks. Wave the flag. Celebrate America’s 250th birthday.
Then, when the last rocket fizzles out and the smoke clears, ask yourself: Are we still trying to build a more perfect union? Or have we settled for building more billionaires?
Keep calm and follow the money!
Clint 🌈✌️
COLLIDE PRESS is a reader-supported publication.
Please consider becoming a Paid Subscriber or Patron.
FROM THE ARCHIVES
BORN THIS WAY ON THIS DAY
07-03 = Franz Kafka (1883-1924) Czech-Austrian author 🌈
MAN CRUSH OF THE DAY
“Anyone who keeps the ability to see beauty never grows old.”
Franz Kafka
What an eloquent and thoughtful essay, well balanced, and true. I still believe in the potential of capitalism to do good things in our world. I don’t mind if somebody is successful and makes a lot of money, but I also want to see them use those resources to help others and to advance opportunities for the many. The very basic application of this would be in the treatment of the very employees who helped you achieve your own success. Are you listening Walmart and Amazon?
Great job Clint and thank you.
Brilliant piece, young man!